On the Planned Obsolescence Of GPS Watches

Recently I have been hesitating between wearing a Garmin Epix Gen 2 that was leant to me, and a Garmin Forerunner 570 that I owned. Whilst thinking about which watch to wear for training I came across a conundrum. If I wear the Epix Gen 2 then I get Endurance and Hill climbing metrics, which is interesting, but I am using a watch that is already retired from the Garmin upgrade cycle.

Rationally, therefore, it makes sense to wear the Garmin Forerunner 570, since it is kept up to date, and upgrades are actively being developed for it and other watches within the same family, as well as certain Fenix watches. Fenix replaced Epix.

When we buy a Casio we’re not buying a watch that has a three or four year shelf life. We are buying a watch that is meant to last for a decade or more between battery changes, but it is designed to last for generations. In theory, at least, they can last as long as we replace watch straps and batteries, much like their analogue counterparts.

This matters because the Suunto Spartan Wrist HR Baro is a great watch, but now it is a piece of history rather than a watch for active use. It is missing features that modern watches have by default. Features such as HRV and more.

I retired the Garmin Instinct Solar not for software reasons but for hardware reasons. I noticed that battery life was degraded and that on long hikes the watch no longer lasted for an entire day’s hiking, so that’s why I replaced it with the Instinct 2.

With the Instinct 2 the watch is still fine, but because I took up running I wanted features that Forerunner series have, that the Instinct 2 doesn’t have. HRV was one, but a clear display to see pace and other information clearly was also important.

The Forerunner 45s was a good cheap watch, just to test running with but it’s a low end, cheap watch, that feels cheap, and not as dependable as the Instinct 2. I was able to borrow an Epix (Gen 2) two or three times. This time I think I can keep it as it has been replaced by another device.

Whilst researching this blog post I noticed that the Garmin Fenix E sells for 299 CHF until the stock runs out. The Garmin Epix (gen 2) went from 1400 CHF, new, to 160 CHF used, and second hand.

When we speak of Apple Watches then we have planned obsolescence that revolves around how old a device is. It only supports the most recent devices fully. With Garmin you have two levels of obsolescence. The first is the product tier. Instinct series watches, and lower number forerunner watches are hobbled to have some functionality. With the mid-tier watches such as the Forerunner 570 it has a lot of features, but lacks those that the 960, 970 and Fenix series have.

The Epix watch, whilst a flagship, top tier watch, is discontinued and thus doesn’t get new features, but it still has gate kept endurance and hill scores.

The Garmin Fenix E that went from 800 CHF to 299 CHF now is interesting if you want premium features at a good price, but I would be wary of the price drop. It may be abandoned shortly. Im this case abandoned simply means no new features. Stability and security updates still continue.

And finally with Garmin I am hitting two walls at once. I am hitting the paywall because features that the Epix and Fenix devices have are paywalled behind premium devices. I can’t get those metrics on the 570. On the other hand the 570 is getting new features that the Epix cannot get because it is now “vintage” to use an Apple term, rather than actively developed for.

Despite no longer being in active development it still makes sense to favour the Epix Gen 2 over the Garmin Forerunner 570 for certain metrics, so it is not obsolete yet. The next question is whether to drop Garmin for Suunto or Coros to avoid this tier issue.